SEASON 1
EPISODE 1
Experience the chilling tale of the Atlanta Ripper, and uncover why his gruesome crimes have been shrouded in obscurity. Listen as we recount the harrowing story of Emma Lou Sharpe, who survived a brutal attack and provided crucial details to the police after her mother, Lena, was found murdered. We explore the social and racial tensions of early 1900s Atlanta—a city grappling with its Confederate past and rapid industrial growth—shedding light on the city’s darker corners where the Ripper roamed.
Join seasoned journalist and acclaimed author Carole Townsend, as she examines how the murders of so many women went unnoticed by newspapers and law enforcement alike, until the crimes could no longer be ignored. Drawing on sources including books and newspaper articles, we’ll piece together why these crimes remain lesser-known, and delve into the historical context that allowed such terror to persist. Don’t miss an opportunity to learn about and understand a critical and shadowy part of Atlanta’s history.
EPISODE 2
The episode begins with the tragic story of Mary Fagan, a 13-year-old girl who went to collect her wages at the National Pencil Company in Atlanta on Confederate Memorial Day in 1913, only to never return home. Her brutalized body was discovered in the factory’s basement, accompanied by incriminating notes that attempted to frame the night watchman. This heart-wrenching story uncovers layers of historical injustice and sets the stage for further exploration of the dark events that followed.
EPISODE 3
What if a ghostly force could shatter the tranquility of your home and torment your family for years? Get ready to uncover the spine-chilling legacy of the Bell Witch, a tale that has baffled and intrigued enthusiasts for over two centuries.
EPISODE 4
What if the dark allure of the underground world could spell both fortune and doom? Join me, Carole Townsend, as we uncover the riveting and sobering tale of Floyd Collins, a passionate cave explorer whose dreams of discovery turned into a harrowing tragedy in Kentucky’s Sand Cave in 1925.
EPISODE 5
Can a lake haunt the living? Join me as I unravel the eerie mysteries of Georgia’s Lake Lanier. Dive deep into the history buried beneath the lake’s waters, including submerged homes, forests, and cemeteries, and learn how these remnants contribute to the lake’s haunted reputation and numerous mysterious deaths. This episode promises to uncover the chilling truth.
EPISODE 6
What if the dark, twisted secrets of New Orleans could chill you to the bone from the comfort of your front porch? Join me, Carole Townsend, as I unravel the sinuous history of the Big Easy, starting with the notorious Madame Delphine LaLaurie. Known as one of history’s most malevolent figures, LaLaurie’s story is one of opulence masking unimaginable cruelty. Step into the haunted corridors of her infamous mansion, where tales of supernatural horror and unspeakable atrocities converge. Discover why her legacy remains one of the most haunting in Southern history, blending high society with horrific truths.
EPISODE 7
Corpsewood Manor, a story that defies conventional wisdom and leaves us questioning the boundaries between idyllic dreams and chilling realities. Dr. Scudder and his partner Joey Odom sought refuge in the Chattahoochee National Forest, constructing a secluded sanctuary far from the mundane grind of Chicago life. Their quest for authenticity and freedom, however, led them into a nightmare on the night of December 12, 1982—a night marked by horror that still echoes through the southern woods.
EPISODE 8
What if the deepest scars of Southern history were hidden within one family’s tragic saga? Join us as we unravel the haunting mystery of the Woolfolk family massacre, a tale rooted in post-Civil War Georgia’s tumultuous soil. Through the eyes of Thomas George Woolfolk, we walk a path littered with personal tragedy, failure, and a legacy of resentment. This episode paints a haunting portrait of a man ensnared by the complex web of family dynamics and Southern tradition, leaving listeners pondering the intricate interplay of emotion and history.
EPISODE 9
What eerie secrets lurk within the walls of King’s Tavern, the oldest building in Natchez, Mississippi, where history and the paranormal intertwine? Journey with me as we unravel the spine-chilling tales of murder and betrayal that haunt this ancient site and explore the historic Natchez Trace, a travel corridor rich with stories of coexistence and conflict. As we gather on my front porch, I promise you’ll be captivated by the legends that echo through this historic site, questioning whether the energies of the past still linger. Expect to be both enthralled and unsettled as we connect the dots between history and ghostly encounters.
EPISODE 10
What if a single word could hold the key to one of America’s oldest mysteries? Join me, Carole Townsend, as we journey through the haunting story of the Lost Colony of Roanoke. Set against the dramatic and often perilous landscape of North Carolina’s Outer Banks, we’ll unravel the complex tapestry of hope, ambition, and possibly tragedy that defined the fateful expedition led by Sir Walter Raleigh in the late 16th century. With only the enigmatic word “Croatoan” as a clue, the disappearance of 117 settlers remains an unsolved puzzle that continues to captivate historians and curious minds alike.
EPISODE 11
Ever wondered what secrets lie beneath the cobblestone streets of Savannah? Join me, as I unravel the ghostly allure and historical intrigue of this Southern city, with tales that will leave you questioning the line between myth and reality. Our journey takes us first to the Mercer House, where the echoes of a dramatic event from May 2, 1981, continue to haunt Savannah’s storied past. Inspired by John Barrett’s “Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil,” we’ll peel back the layers of Southern charm to discover a city where history, mystery, and idiosyncratic characters create an irresistible tapestry.
EPISODE 12
Could a life of crime be born from the pages of a fashion magazine? Join me, Carole Townsend, as we uncover the thrilling story of Doris Payne, the woman who turned the allure of Harper’s Bazaar into a blueprint for an extraordinary life as a master jewel thief. Raised amid the challenges of poverty, domestic violence, and racial inequality in 1930s West Virginia, Doris defied the odds stacked against her. From her audacious heist of a $20,000 diamond ring to the international escapades that followed, Doris’s story is a fascinating mix of charm, skill, and boldness, each step drawing her further into the spotlight of Southern folklore.
EPISODE 13
Discover the shocking crime spree of Carl Isaacs and his gang, whose violent escape from the Maryland State Penitentiary led to a terrifying series of events in 1973. How did a group of fugitives leave a trail of car thefts, burglaries, and brutal murders across several states? Unravel the gripping narrative of their journey southward, culminating in the harrowing Alday family massacre in Donaldsonville, Georgia, an event that left an indelible mark on the community and the justice system.
EPISODE 14
On Christmas morning in 1945, a family’s holiday joy shattered when flames consumed their home and five children mysteriously vanished. The Sodder family of Fayetteville, West Virginia, faced unthinkable tragedy that sparked theories of conspiracy and kidnapping. Starting with a strange phone call that Jenny Sautter received just before the blaze began, the episode delves into the moments leading to the horrifying fire that would change their lives forever.
EPISODE 15
A mother’s desperate claim that her two young sons were kidnapped by a carjacker unravels into one of the most shocking murder cases in South Carolina history. The Susan Smith case reveals how a web of lies, inconsistencies, and a devastating confession led to the discovery of a premeditated crime that shocked the nation.